Chicago Theatre Review

Chicago Theatre Review

Beyond Historic, A Triumph of the Human Spirit and Infinitely Compassionate Faith

November 16, 2026 Reviews No Comments

Omar

A testament to the enduring human spirit, Omar is the story of a deeply spiritual Islamic scholar who is kidnapped into slavery but maintains his faith and his dignity, with his writing as an essential act of survival. The Pulitzer Prize winning score (2023) soars with the story that is based on the hand-written autobiography of Omar ibn Said. Presented by the Lyric Opera of Chicago in this, the United States’ 250th anniversary, the work broadens the limits of our selectively-curated national narrative and challenges us to acknowledge the inextricably-bound beauty and brutality of our history. As for so many – our ancestors, our neighbors, our selves perhaps – ‘America never was America’ for the human beings at the center of Omar.

The Lyric Opera of Chicago once again delivers a historic and ground-breaking work that expands the embrace and relevance of opera itself. Commissioned in 2019 but delayed by COVID, Omar premiered at the 2022 Spoleto Festival, less than a mile from the site where the man and main character Omar ibn Said was sold into slavery. Chicago audiences bear witness to Omar’s experiences – privation, dehumanization, raw survival – through the frame of the Civic Opera House auditorium’s ornate proscenium and gilded walls; a juxtaposition with inexorable implications.

Co-composer and librettist Rhiannon Giddens adds Omar to her long list of stellar successes. A MacArthur Genius grant recipient, Pulitzer Prize winner, two-time Grammy Award-winner, composer for multiple forums, author and publisher, Giddens is virtually superhuman in her accomplishments. She is the current Artistic Director of Silk Road Ensemble, hosts a television show on PBS, and is a founding member of two extraordinary and revelatory musical groups, the Carolina Chocolate Drops and Our Native Daughters. And these are just a tiny fraction of her creative gifts to the world.

Co-composer Michael Abels is a three-time Emmy nominee, a Grammy nominee, and recipient of the Pulitzer Prize. His orchestral and symphonic works have been lauded in performances across the country, and Abels’ scores for film and television are award-winning, including a World Soundtrack Award and a Jerry Goldsmith Award for the Jordan Peele film Us.

Giddens and Abels weave Omar’s music from threads that are as varied and complex as the individual lines of the African Diaspora. The velvet intervals of traditional Islamic prayer, the resonance of Spirituals, the mourning of the Blues, and the echoing power of the banjo embodied in the syncopation of the orchestral arrangement itself – all make appearances, shaping and transforming many of the production’s typical operatic forms. The orchestral and vocal scores are sublime, perfect in each emotional beat; violins wailing in loss, percussive cracks, voices perfectly intertwining or deliberately discordant. The entire company is flawless.

The dramatic and musical demands of Omar’s journey are fully-realized in the bold, resounding voice of acclaimed tenor Issachah Savage in the title role. Savage exudes an unshakeable presence, such that even in Omar’s deepest crises he is still somehow the calm, still, center in the middle of the whirlwind. Celebrated for dynamic tenor and heldentenor roles, Savage has performed with many of the world’s leading orchestras and major opera houses, after sweeping the 2014 Seattle International Wagner Competition, capturing the main prize, audience favorite, orchestra favorite, as well as a special honor from Speight Jenkins.

Award-winning soprano Kearstin Piper Brown is transportive as Julie, a fiery woman who escapes the auction block and inspires Omar – both to join her in relative safety in Fayetteville and to fulfill his destiny through writing. Brown’s voice is a glorious instrument, and she wields it with a thrilling passion and a precision that never errs, giving life to Julie from the edge of despair to exultant heights. She has performed in major roles at opera houses across the country, earning multiple honors, including the Theatre World Award for Outstanding Debut Performance in an Off-Broadway Production for her creation of the title role of Esther in Ricky Ian Gordon’s Intimate Apparel at the Lincoln Center Theater.

There is a potent thread that weaves through the libretto of Omar, transmuting familiar history into intimate, individual experience. Sometimes this thread is a simple phrase, sometimes a shifted perspective. Whatever form, it has the power to slice through that which inures us to the horrors of the past, transforming academic knowledge into emotional understanding; laying bare the human experience at the center.

Moments from the Middle Passage scene are brilliant examples of this effect. Torturous confinement shatters one man into amnesic madness that is visceral. Another seeks psychological escape reliving the sound of his mother’s voice, the taste of her cooking – a strangled conclusion of “it helps” sears his suffering into truth. Those who escape the ship through death tell their own stories even as they join in a choral prayer for Yemaya’s transportive powers. In another scene the known evil of ripping apart families at human auctions is wrenchingly real through a heartbreaking shift, as a father is compelled to hawk the value of his own child in a desperate attempt to stay together.

Omar is appropriately celebrated as a story unique in it’s perspective and primary source material; a portrait of a man otherwise unfamiliar in the chronicles of United States chattel slavery. Similarly, and relatedly, the piece also gives audiences a view of Allah and Islamic worship that is not commonly presented in Western entertainment. Prayers are sung in a language that is ‘other’ but with sentiments of “infinitely compassionate”, sustaining and abundant love that flows from and to the Divine – sentiments that would be at home in a typical Christian hymn. A deeply spiritual man, Omar wrestles with a crisis of faith because of the circumstances he is forced to endure; a familiar theme in biblical tales.

These so familiar central tenets build resonance with the Western audience despite the less familiar context. And then, repeatedly, brutally, those sentiments are juxtaposed with Christian invocations that highlight the obscenity of enslavement. A slave-ship sailor invokes Jesus Christ regarding the hellish conditions forced on the captive below decks. An auctioneer promises humans as property ‘by my faith guaranteed.’ An enslaver seeks social and divine approval in attempting to convert Omar to Christianity, while maintaining Omar’s enslavement, denying his basic humanity.

The set (Amy Rubin, Set Designer) is a masterstroke, billowing sheaths continuously transformed to shape the space. Frequently these form graceful, tenuous boughs on a central post, once a ship’s mast, more often a vastly spreading tree. The tree’s sheltering physical form invites gathering, deliberately mirrored in scenes set in Senegal and in North Carolina. It also calls to mind a family tree form, with the branches a mix of solid structure and ephemeral fabric spun in words, contemplating the tenuous linking of familial history for those ripped from their kin and culture.

The Lyric Opera of Chicago production was directed by storied Kaneza Schaal, the work’s original 2022 director. Under Schaal’s brilliant and encompassing vision, Omar is a spiritual experience in virtually every moment. Her devotion to the history and the human stories, and her love for the human beings living it, inform each exquisitely purposeful detail. Schaal’s manifestation of this epic is flawless.

The creative team includes Clarissa Marie Ligon as Associate Director, April M. Hickman original Costume Designer, Charlese Antoinette Jones Costume Designer, Pablo Santiago Lighting Designer, Joshua Higgason Projection Designer, Michael Black Chorus Director, and John Metzner Wig and Makeup Designer.

Audiences should hope that this extraordinary experience returns to Chicago.

Highly Recommended

Reviewed by Soleil Rodrigue

Omar presented by Lyric Opera of Chicago had a limited run at the Lyric Opera House, October 23-28. Audiences should clamor for its return. For current productions visit www.lyricopera.org/shows/upcoming

Additional information about this and other area productions can be found by visiting www.theatreinchicago.com


0 comments


Leave a Reply